Matsumoto versus Mori

A Free King and a Dragon King handicap game

White's Free King and left-side Dragon King are removed from the board, and their squares are occupied by the Vertical Movers. The Ferocious Leopard in turn occupy the squares vacated by the Vertical Movers, and then White starts the game.

1.Ln - 7e
2P - 8hP - 5e
3P - 5hP - 8e
4P - 7hLn - 7f
5Ky - 7iP - 3e
6Ln - 5iP - 6e
7Ph - 7k 

This looks odd. I presume Matsumoto was concerned to over-protect 7h and 5h, but the Phoenix definitely belongs on 8i.

7DH - 2e
8Ph - 7jP - 6f

Going for an early push in the centre, to make use of the Vertical Movers. I think this is too early.

9DK - 6kVM 7c - 6c
10C - 4kP - 5f
11P - 7g 

There seems to be no point in sacrificing this Pawn at this moment.

11Ln x! 7g
12P - 6hP - 7e
13C - 5jFL - 3d
14C - 6iPh - 7c

Another unusual Phoenix move. This time the Phoenix is destined for 5e, so it must go via 7c rather than 5d, otherwise the fifth-file Pawn falls.

15P - 3hGB - 4f
16DH - 2hFL - 4e
17DK 8j - 7kPh - 5e
18FK - 5jDK - 7b
19FK - 3lC - 9b
20R - 6jC - 8c
21VM - 3jC - 7d
22FL - 2kP - 10e
23P - 10hDH - 11e
24DH - 11hFL - 10d
25R - 8jGB - 9f
26VM - 10jFL - 9e
27C - 9kS - 9b
28S - 4kS - 8c
29C - 9jC - 4b
30C - 8iC - 4c
31FL - 11kC - 5d
32S - 9kC 5d - 6e
33C 8i - 7hS - 4b
34S - 9jBT - 9c

It seems advancing the Blind Tigers and the Gold Generals was typical in these games. I like neither.

35G - 9kG - 9b
36P - 1hB - 9a
37FL - 2jP - 1e
38P - 3gP - 6g
39P x 6gLn x! 6g
40FL - 3iC - 6f
41S - 5jC 7d - 6e
42C - 6hS - 7d
43S - 6iS - 4c
44FL - 3hG - 4b
45GB - 4gPh - 5d
46P 4i - 4hS - 3d
47DH - 4jP - 3f
48P x 3fFL x 3f
49GB x 4fS - 3e
50GB - 4gP - 4e
51DH - 4iKy - 6d
52G - 4kG - 4c
53FK - 2lG - 4d
54BT - 4jDE - 8b
55K - 8l 

A difficult decision. I think it is too early to move the King, as it is not yet clear which side it should move to. For the moment, the centre is in no danger of opening up.

55B - 11c
56DE - 7lK - 7a

White has already committed his King to moving this way, so he may as well get it out of the centre now. With both Kings moving the same way, we can expect a fierce struggle in front of them. White has a slight space advantage on this side.

57S - 8iK - 8a
58P - 12hP - 12e
59P - 2hK - 9a
60SM - 1iKy - 8d
61FL - 11jK - 10a
62K - 9lDH - 11f
63DH - 12iKy - 10d
64P - 11hP - 12f
65DH - 11iBT - 8d
66FL - 10iP - 10f
67SM - 12iLn - 8f
68C 6h - 6gP - 10g
69Ln - 7hKy - 10f
70P - 8gLn x! 8g
71Ky - 8hLn - 10e
72C x 6fC x 6f
73B - 11jDH - 11e
74VM - 10lP - 8f
75BT - 5iG - 5e
76R - 10jDH - 3d
77P x 10gKy - 10d
78GB - 9gP - 4f
79FL - 9hS - 8e
80G - 5jP - 7f
81Ky - 8jB - 10b
82Ph - 7iBT - 7e
83BT - 7jBT - 4c
84DE - 8kPh - 4d
85Ln - 8hBT - 5d
86S - 7hBT 5d - 6e
87BT 7j - 6iPh - 4e
88DK 7k - 6lDH - 4d
89B - 4jG - 5d
90S - 9jGB x 9g
91FL x 9gS 8e - 9f
92S 9j - 8iS x 9g
93Ph x 9gDH - 12d
94Ln - 10hP - 7g

White takes advantage of Black's over-crowding in the centre. If Black played S - 9h instead of Ln - 10h, then FL - 9f would be harsh.

95C x 7gC x 7g
96S x 7gDH x 7g
97BT - 6hDH - 4d
98BT 6i - 7hBT - 8e
99BT - 7gBT 6e - 7f
100G - 6iG - 6e
101G - 6hVM - 7c
102BT 7h - 6gFL - 9f
103DH - 5jLn - 9e
104Ph - 9hVM 5c - 6c
105S - 8hB - 7e
106DH - 10iB - 4b
107DH - 9jPh - 5e
108Ln - 11gP - 8g
109S - 7iFL - 9g
110S - 7hLn - 9f

I don't know what is going on here. Why doesn't Black retreat the Phoenix, and why doesn't White capture it?

The answer to the second question may perhaps be that Mori feels he can't afford to capture the Phoenix, as he will not have sufficient attack, and Matsumoto's defences will start to look in good shape after P x 9h.

As for why Matsumoto is worried about the centre, I don't know. After Ph - 7j, BT x 6g, BT x 6g and all is secure. After Ph - 7j, Ph x 7f, BT x 7f, and again everything is solid. Perhaps Matsumoto wanted Mori to play FL x 9h. Then after P x 9h the Side Movers are in communication and the centre is solid. But in that case, why did he withdraw the Phoenix at move 113, instead of playing Ln x! 12f first.

111BT x 7fG x 7f
112BT - 6gG - 8f
113Ph - 7jKy - 11e
114Ln - 10iLn x! 10g
115Ln - 8iKy - 10f
116P - 9hFL - 10h
117Ky - 9iFL x 9i =
118Ln x! 9iDH - 12e
119Ph - 8jBT - 9e
120DK 6k - 7lLn - 8e
121DH - 9iR - 5c
122DK - 7kB - 3c
123R - 7jLn - 9f
124P - 2gVM - 8c
125S - 7gVM - 7c
126Ln - 7hB - 4a
127SM - 11iLn - 7e
128GB x 4fB - 9f
129DH - 5kP - 8h
130Ln x 8h - 7iLn - 8g
131P - 9gLn x 9g
132Ln - 9jLn - 8e
133FL - 4gFL x 4g
134P x 4gDH x 7j+

Now with Matsumoto just freeing his position, and strating to attack on his right flank, Mori makes his play, but it does not look sound.

135DK x 7jKy - 9g
136R x 10c+SM x 10c
137DH - 10jKy x 7g
138BT x 7gG x 7g
139G x 7gPh x 7g

Now if Black were to try to give back some material with B x 7g, VM x 7g, DH x 7g, DH x 7g, FK - 2i, he would have a reasonbly easy endgame.

140B - 1gPh - 7f
141DH x 4d+B x 4d
142B x 3ePh x 5h
143B x 4d+VM x 7j+
144DK x 7jDK x 7j+
145DE x 7jPh x 3j+
146+B x 5cSM x 5c
147DH - 1gLn - 6d
148FK - 6lLn - 5e
149FK - 6aDE - 9a
150SM 1i - 6iVM - 7c
151G - 8kVM - 6c
152FK - 2aP - 1f
153DH - 3i+Ph - 3l
154K - 9kLn - 7g
155Ln - 9hLn - 7h
156SM - 5iB - 8e
157B - 10kLn - 8f
158B x 5fB - 7d
159B x 7d+Ln x 7d

Matsumoto is ahead by a Phoenix and a Dragon Horse. He now prevents the Vertical Mover from promoting, which was not a threat. FK - 7f looks a reasonable move to keep the initiative, and this would also stop Mori's next move.

160SM 11i - 6i+Ph - 2k
161DH - 4i+Ph - 2h
162Ln - 7fVM - 7c
163FK x 2dSM - 5d

Now Ln x 5d fails to FK - 9h, and FK x 5d fails to Ln x 5d, Ln x 5d, FK - 9h (though Black is probably just ahead after the latter variation).

164FK - 3e+Ph x 11h
165G - 9j 

This weakens the Drunk Elephant. K - 8l looks better to me.

165Ln - 9f
166Ln - 6hLn - 9h

FK x 6h would leave White without sufficient material.

167VM x 10c+K - 11a
168FK - 6e 

+VM - 10k looks good. Now Mori gets a chance to go for mate, and the game turns around.

168+Ph x 9j
169Ph x 9jLn x 7j
170K - 10jLn - 8k
171K - 11iLn x 9j
172K - 12iG x 10c

This clears the way for Ln - 10k/j/h mate, so Matsumoto simply resigns.

If he were to play on:

173FK - 6fK - 11b
174Ln - 8hLn - 11k
175K - 11hLn x 12k - 11j
176K - 10gVM - 7k+
177Ln - 9g+VM - 7j
178SM - 8iLn - 9j
179K - 9fLn x 8i - 7h Mate